I’ve put together my years of experience both as a classically trained professional pastry chef and a strict keto and low carb diet follower to create my list of recommended keto baking ingredients. Enjoy!
Keto Friendly Sweeteners
Swerve measures cup for cup like sugar, and is one of the most popular keto-friendly sweeteners out there. Most people don’t experience any aftertaste, although some get a cooling sensation. In addition to erythritol, it also contains oligosaccharides, so some people might experience digestive discomfort. Swerve, like all erythritol, tends to recrystallize when it cools.
Pure granulated erythritol is around 70% as sweet as sugar. The brand I’m linking here is a favorite and gets fantastic reviews. Most importantly, the only ingredient is erythritol. If you purchase another brand, be sure to watch out for sneaky, keto-unfriendly ingredients, such as dextrose or maltodextrin (essentially just other names for types of sugar). Erythritol also tends to recrystallize when it cools.
Allulose is one of my favorite sweeteners To me, it tastes more like sugar than any other keto-friendly sweetener! Allulose is a non-nutritive sweetener called a rare sugar, and as a Type 1 Diabetic, I love that I don’t have to bolus any insulin for it (meaning that it has absolutely zero effect on my blood sugar). Allulose also carmelizes really well (even better than sucrose), and it doesn’t recrystallize in cooled baked goods like erythritol does. Since allulose doesn’t ferment very well in the gut, it may also be a great choice for those that have digestive problems with Swerve or erythritol.
Confectioners swerve is simply the powdered version of granulated Swerve! Don’t want Swerve? So Nourished also makes powdered pure erythritol that you can find by clicking here. OR, if you just don’t want to buy a separate product, you can always make your own powdered Swerve, erythritol, or allulose by buzzing the granulated versions in a blender (I’ve done this many times in my Nutribullet and it works very well).
Swerve’s brown sugar substitute is similar to their granulated sweetener, but the flavor really is a lot like brown sugar. It also has a higher moisture content, so you can pack it into a measuring cup in the same way. This is my favorite brown sugar substitute out there right now!
Keto Friendly Chocolate Chips
Lily’s Sugar-Free Dark Chocolate Chips are sweetened with erythritol, inulin, and stevia, and they’re about the same size and texture as regular chocolate chips. They’re not cheap, so I usually buy a multi-pack to save a bit of money.
KNOW Foods Know Better Chocolate Chips are only sweetened with allulose, so if you have digestive discomfort with Lily’s chocolate chips, you might want to try these. They are a little smaller than regular chocolate chips and seem to my taste buds to have a lower fat content. They are slightly sweeter, crunchier and burn a little easier than Lily’s. All that said, I LOVE them, and I LOVE having the option of allulose sweetened chocolate chips.
Keto Friendly Flours
I only use and recommend Bob’s Red Mill Coconut Flour. Different brands of coconut flour vary in their absorbency, so it’s always best to use the brand the recipe was created with. I have always gotten the best results with Bob’s Red Mill Coconut Flour. It also happens to be the brand of coconut flour most commonly used by recipe bloggers, so it’s likely to give you the most consistent outcomes across the board.
I recently found that I’m sensitive to almonds, but previously I used and loved Wellbee’s Super Fine Almond Flour. Try to avoid almond meal, which is much coarser. You’ll get much better results with super fine almond flour. I recommend buying a 2 or 5 lb bag to get a lower price per lb. Freeze whatever you aren’t using right away to keep it fresh.
Other Keto Friendly Ingredients
Most cinnamon you’ll find at the grocery store is actually made from Cassia bark which is often called “fake cinnamon” by serious foodies. Truthfully, both Ceylon and Cassia are from trees in the Cinnamomum genus, making them both real cinnamon. Cassia tends to be hotter and spicier tasting however, while Ceylon has a sweeter and more complex flavor. I personally prefer the flavor of Ceylon cinnamon.
Nielsen-Massey has been my absolute favorite brand of vanilla extract since my days of working as a professional pastry chef. If you want to up your baking game, I can’t recommend it highly enough!
I love the soft tissue benefits of taking collagen peptides, so I put a scoop in my morning coffee every day! But this is also a great addition to many keto baking recipes. I often use collagen in cookie recipes, as it helps to add a nice chewy texture that coconut flour doesn’t provide.
Unlike collagen, gelatin will gel cold liquids. And while I love making homemade low carb jello with keto-friendly Bai drinks, gelatin does so much more. For example, it’s integral to my amazing fluffy and firm keto marshmallow recipe. It does need to be bloomed in cold liquid before dissolving in hot liquid, so I keep both collagen peptides and gelatin in my pantry for convenience’s sake.
Real heavy cream powder is one of the main ingredients in my homemade keto hot chocolate mix recipe. I just love having low carb hot chocolate mix handy at all times! It’s such an easy and healthy way to satisfy a chocolate craving.
I love to say that pork rinds are the cauliflower of the keto baking world because they’re so useful! I crush them up to use in my cheesecake crusts, and they’re the perfect substitute for carb filled cereal in my keto-friendly faux Chex party mix. My favorite pork rinds to use in recipes are Epic’s Artisinal Oven Baked Pink Himalayan Sea Salt Pork Rinds. They have a mild flavor that doesn’t overpower the other ingredients and since they’re oven baked, they’re not super greasy.
As part of my low carb diet, I’ve also eliminated inflammatory cooking oils like vegetable and corn oil. Avocado oil is now my favorite cooking oil because of its high smoke point and neutral flavor. I use and recommend Primal Kitchen’s avocado oil.
I’ll often grease baking pans with softened butter but there are some situations where pan spray is much more convenient, so I always keep it on hand. I use and recommend Primal Kitchen’s avocado oil pan spray.
It’s SO important to use fresh baking soda when baking. If you’re not getting great results, old baking soda could be to blame. Amazon has a hidden gem with its 365 Everyday Value Baking Soda. It’s a fantastic bargain!
Just like baking powder, it’s super important to replace your baking powder regularly to get the best results. Luckily Amazon has an amazing deal on their baking powder too! I recommend their 365 Everyday Value baking powder, and it’s crazy inexpensive!
Parchment paper is one of the most important things that I have in my kitchen. I absolutely couldn’t bake without it! Most rolls don’t have much parchment paper on them though, so I like to buy these 205 square foot rolls because they last so much longer.
I’ve been cooking and baking for a looong time and I’m very picky about aluminum foil. Reynolds heavy duty aluminum foil is the best of the best! It’s much thicker than standard aluminum foil, which means it doesn’t rip as easily (fewer messes!). I’ve tried other heavy duty brands and nothing else compares. I like to buy Reynolds heavy duty in the 75 square foot roll because it’s much wider than a standard roll, making it easy to completely cover a cookie sheet with one piece of foil.